Vegan nutrition in other circumstances and for the little ones
Interview with Carmen Hercegfi Part 2: Baby-led weaning
Introducing babies to solid foods and feeding them a purely plant-based diet from the very first bite - is that possible? Carmen Hercegfi uses her wealth of knowledge as a vegan, mother and nutritionist for vegan family nutrition to tell us about the baby-led weaning method, what you need to pay particular attention to and her own experiences with it.
With baby-led weaning, the child decides for themselves
With baby-led weaning, the child weans itself from milk to solid food. Keimling-interview, Carmen Hercegfi explains why she considers baby-led weaning to be the best form of infant feeding. She gives us an insight into her everyday life with baby-led weaning and has a few tips to share - including cold-pressed oils, hemp seeds, chia seeds, sprouts and Keimlinge.
Tip: Can't watch the video right now? Read the 2nd part of the interview!
Carmen Hercegfi on baby-led weaning - Part 2 of the interview to read:
Verena: Dear Carmen, you gave birth to your second son, little Yannik, in February 2015 - lively and healthy. With your son, you are trying out a different approach to the "average mum". You are feeding your Yannik using the baby-led weaning method. What exactly is that?
Carmen Hercegfi: Baby-led weaning is actually a very modern term for something that has actually been around for as long as we humans have existed. I don't think our ancestors had blenders and complementary feeding schedules. The term was coined by a British midwife, Gill Rapley.
Baby-led weaning means that the baby weans itself from the breast. The baby is left to wean itself from the breast and get used to complementary foods at its own pace. One thing is to pay close attention to the child's signs and not say that the baby is now four, five or six months old and you could start with this or that porridge.
Take a close look: can the baby sit up on its own? Is the baby really showing enough interest? There are signs that you should look out for. As a rule, it really only starts at six months. For some children even later. And the breast remains the main source of nourishment at the beginning.
Children come directly to the family table and not at one year when you make the transition from porridge to the family table. The children come directly to the table at every meal and then get finger food.
That works quite well. But for the first one or two months, there's not so much coming in because they're still very preoccupied with how to touch it, how to get it in. Then everything comes out first, just like with porridge.
Gill Rapley's book explains it really well. It's also great for mums who are often so stressed: Everything comes out again, my God, why doesn't it keep it in? Why doesn't it learn? Why is he pushing the spoon out? These are actually protective functions. Children could choke and choke on it. And that's the exploration in the mouth first and then it comes out. It's not about eating yet.
If you do this baby-led weaning, then you know that and deal with it in a very relaxed way. The book by Gill Rapley and Tracey Murkett is really nice. It also has a few photos in it. You can see a bit of what it looks like when the children are sitting at the family table.
"I also have a good wholemeal rye bread that he eats. I'll put nut butter on it for him."
Verena: How does Yannik take to the complementary food? What does he like, what doesn't he like at all? Is that already crystallising in him?
Carmen Hercegfi: He finds everything exciting. Of course he loves what he can eat well. Peaches and nectarines are great. They don't fall apart and are held together really well by the skin and he can suck them off really well. Plums, on the other hand, are far too firm. They fall out of his hand and he can't get them off.
I also have a good wholemeal rye bread that he eats. I put nut butter on it for him. Cashew butter, he also eats sesame butter, although it's not sweet at all. Lightly steamed broccoli, if it's steamed too much it falls apart too quickly.
I also give him cucumber and carrots, even if they are not steamed. But that's more for the flavour, he doesn't get anything yet. He can suck the cucumber, courgettes from the oven.
Lots of things from the oven with a little good olive oil and herbs - no salt! It's really important to avoid salt in the first year of life because the kidneys can't cope with it yet.
"Babies need a month or two before significant amounts reach the stomach. Otherwise you continue breastfeeding..."
Verena: What does a typical daily meal plan look like for you?
Carmen Hercegfi: In the morning I usually have lots of fruit and so that he has something to really fill him up, he gets a loaf of bread. He just sucks it off. Sometimes, when I make porridge, he also gets a porridge. Then I have millet flakes and pour boiling water over them. And then I squeeze in a banana or a spoonful of nut butter and then I take a DHA-enriched linseed oil.
That's very important. I have one at the moment that has lemon oil in it. I stir it in when the porridge has cooled down a bit. Then he sometimes gets the spoon. I just think to myself, I eat porridge sometimes too, so he has to have it sometimes.
At lunchtime, I try steamed things or something from the oven, including fruit, and then make sure I have a filling side dish. These are potatoes or sweet potatoes. If I only eat a salad myself, he gets avocado, for example, which is great. I also love mango on a salad, for example. He really likes that.
Mango seeds are really cool, by the way. He has African roots and in Africa children get mango seeds and suck them off. That's totally great.
And then, of course, if I haven't made anything else, he gets wholemeal spelt pasta. The spiralised noodles are great. If necessary, he also gets half a slice of bread with something on it so that he's full.
Verena: Critics say that babies just suck on it, they don't eat it properly and then they don't get full and don't get everything they need.
Carmen Hercegfi: It really is the case that babies need one or two months before significant quantities reach their stomachs. Otherwise you continue to breastfeed and there are also children who are fully breastfed for nine or ten months and are doing great, but who refuse any porridge before that. The mum is so stressed because the paediatricians say: "But that's not possible, it has to eat porridge already." Then they're just not ready yet and they're breastfed for longer.
At the moment, I'm still breastfeeding ten times at night (laughs). Just now again, I've already had two in between. And I'm still breastfeeding several times during the day. I don't know how much he drinks then either, but I always let him feed when he wants to. That means I don't have to worry. And he also gets nutrients from sucking.
As I said, the first month or two, you just have to know that. It just takes that long for the child to learn to explore the food, to get it small with the palate before teeth are there and until he can swallow it.
Ultimately, you can tell how much has gone in by the contents of the nappy. It went away relatively quickly from the breast milk stool, which is so liquid-yellow. I started a lot with banana, you can already see the banana coming through (laughs). And after two or three weeks it was solid. That's about how long it took. And if he eats less well now, then it will become a bit more fluid again.
I'm not worried at the moment. I can see that it's working better and better, day by day. And in an emergency, I always have a look at the book and read all the testimonials. There are baby-led weaning groups on Facebook. And there's even a vegan/vegetarian baby-led weaning group.
Verena: So dear readers, if you're unsure, if you have questions, if you want to network - you'll find what you're looking for on Facebook!
Carmen, you now have a direct comparison between your first son, who you fed with porridge, and Yannik, who is now on baby-led weaning. Which is the more time-consuming feeding for you when you take everything together - the mess, cleaning the baby?
Carmen Hercegfi: The mess is a bit bigger at the moment. But I think it's just spread out with my big one. With the jars, there was also endless mess. And then at some point he has to learn to eat it himself and then there's more mess. And now I have everything at once, so to speak.
I've been doing it for six weeks now. In these six weeks, however, I've really noticed how little ends up on the floor. In the beginning, everything landed on the floor and now it's just really slippery things that fall over the edge of the tray. I have this really cheap chair from IKEA that you can put completely in the shower and rinse off once.
And from cooking, I have to confess to my shame that I bought jars for my first son eleven years ago. I did buy a super blender at some point, but in the beginning I preferred to use jars.
It's also time-consuming with the jars. You have to buy them separately, you don't just have some at home. Once they're gone, they're gone. And then you have to warm them up and everything. And now I just cook something for myself and see whether he can eat it all or not.
"I find it more relaxed now [...] because I can eat at the same time and he's busy."
I only add salt once I've eaten his portion. And he can eat just about anything. Normal green salad is difficult now. But he once held a steamed savoy cabbage leaf in his hand, for example. He thought that was great because he could hold it really well. That worked really well.
I find it more relaxed now. But it's always a bit of an effort when the children are sitting at the table and learning. One way or another. But I think it's cooler now because I can eat at the same time and he's busy.
At the beginning, it's best to breastfeed the child first so that it's not hungry. Because the child doesn't get full by eating. And so it can try things out a bit.
There are so many more great things that I can't even mention right now that support development. I simply recommend reading the book. Whether it's this one or not, I think there are two or three others. I only know this one now. I would definitely recommend it to anyone starting out.
Because doctors can't help you. I told my paediatrician, who is basically very open anyway, who of course also knows my background and said: "Then you can tell me something."
And then she asked me: "Have you started complementary feeding yet?" when we had our last check-up. I said, yes, we started with baby-led weaning. Do you know that? "No." Then I showed her a video of him eating the broccoli and she said: "That the children can already do that."
She was really surprised and then I wrote the book down for her and she said: "Yes, I'm definitely going to get that." I said I would recommend it, because in England it's actually replacing normal complementary feeding and a lot of people are already doing baby-led weaning instead of porridge. And I think that this will also happen in Germany.
"... the current recommendations from the FKE, which is the Research Institute of Paediatric Nutrition, and also the "Gesund ins Leben" network say: raw food oils - no problem at all."
Verena: What are babies allowed to eat? There are all sorts of things where there are question marks: Chia seeds, for example, hemp seeds. What else can you think of that people might need to watch out for?
Carmen Hercegfi: The classic things are yes, no honey in the first year of life, because it's raw and there are certain germs in it. It doesn't apply to vegans now, but I still wanted to mention it again because many are perhaps already predominantly vegan but still have honey. That's one of those things where you have to be careful.
Salt is one thing that is really dangerous, as are nuts. But nuts not because of the ingredients, but because of ingestion. And that also applies up to the age of three. And even after that really only at the table if they eat the nuts like that. My main lecturer told me that this applies in some cases up to the age of ten, i.e. only at the table. Not that they run around the house with a handful of peanuts.
I qualified as a childminder back then and also did a first aid course for children, and of course it's not without its dangers, nuts getting stuck in the windpipe and then starting to swell up.
Verena: What about cold-pressed oil?
Carmen Hercegfi: I asked a few more questions last week at the "Vegan from the start" seminar organised by the UGB, the Association for Independent Health Advice, and asked the wonderful lecturer Edith Gätjen. She has written many books and has four children of her own. She trains specialist counsellors for infant and child nutrition, midwives and breastfeeding counsellors.
I asked her again about the raw food oil and she said, no, the current recommendations from the FKE, the Research Institute for Child Nutrition, and also the "Gesund ins Leben" network say: raw food oils - no problem at all. I've been using them for six weeks now.
I personally haven't triedchia seeds yet. But I haven't heard anything to the contrary from her either. I simply wouldn't take so much of these foods that are still so "new". I wouldn't overdo it. The little one has already had hemp seeds.



Carmen Hercegfi: I haven't personally given them to him yet. But I can also tell you from pregnancy, because there are often warnings about sprouts. And I think it's really important to grow sprouts and Keimlinge yourself and not buy them in the supermarket. Because you really don't know what's happened to them, is there anything wrong with them.
I would try it when the babies are already a bit fitter with food. And I would also only take them home-grown and maybe, if it's too warm, try making them in the fridge if the temperature works. Just as a tip.
That's also what I know about pregnancy and I would do the same for the children. That wouldn't necessarily be what I would start with. But if there are a few in there somewhere, I don't find it problematic at all. I would give it a try.
"I sometimes give him a porridge in the evening in the hope that he'll eat a bit more,
so that I don't have to breastfeed ten times."
Verena: Have you tried pulses yet?
Carmen Hercegfi: Yes, I was always warned a bit about them. I recently made lentil rolls. I don't know how much ended up in my stomach, but it wasn't a problem at all.
Verena: Now you've tried both - baby food and baby-led weaning. What do you think is the ideal form of nutrition for babies?
Carmen Hercegfi: For me, baby-led weaning. And if you just say, you know, it's not all black or white. Yannik is also brown. You can also just combine it a bit. Nobody stands behind you and says you can't have the porridge now. I sometimes give him a porridge in the evening in the hope that he will eat a bit more so that I don't have to breastfeed ten times.
Apart from that, baby-led weaning is in line with nature and is less stressful than pure porridge feeding. At least if you have familiarised yourself with baby-led weaning. Then you become a little more relaxed, even if you decide in favour of porridge. Because you simply know a bit of the background, why they spit it out and so on.
Verena: Do you have any tips for mums-to-be who are also considering baby-led weaning? You've already mentioned the book by Gill Rapley and Tracey Murkett. Is there perhaps another website?
Carmen Hercegfi: There is actually a German baby-led weaning website. I had a quick look at it once, but I haven't surfed around on it any further. You can definitely have a look there to get some initial ideas. Or in the Facebook groups. I think they also have documents that briefly explain the short principle.
I think there will be more and more of that now. And otherwise I would definitely read through the book. Just to see what works and what the tricks are, how the children can eat it best. I also found the testimonials in there really great.
Verena: Now we want to do a bit of advertising for you. You're currently writing your own book. Can you say anything about it yet? Does it already have a title? When will it be published? Where does it appear? Where can we get it?
Carmen Hercegfi: We have a working title at the moment, which is the same name as my blog - Vegan in other circumstances. I don't know yet whether we'll leave it as it is or come up with something else. Maybe "Becoming a mum with a vegan pregnancy and breastfeeding".
A few months ago I met a very nice lady, Sarah Gebhardt, who runs the blog Pflanzenhunger.de, and I asked her if she would like to take part because she is an ecotrophologist and she does such a great job with the nutrients.
She said yes straight away and we've now split up, she's doing the whole nutrition part because she also wrote her bachelor's thesis on nutrients and vegan pregnancy. This means that she is very used to this scientific work and I can let off steam creatively with the recipes.
But there is still a lot of information on the outside - breastfeeding, losing weight after pregnancy, dieting - yes or no? No, of course (laughs). But how do you do that? So many things.
We found a really great vegan publisher, Grüner Sinn. The book is produced completely vegan. So the printing is also vegan and the whole way there. We just signed the contract two or three weeks ago and are really looking forward to it. It will be published next year, at the end of next year. If we're quick, maybe sooner, if we're slow, then it'll be a bit later (laughs). We're really busy planning for next year.
Verena: Under the Christmas tree in 2016?
Carmen Hercegfi: Yes, that would be great. We definitely want to make it so beautiful that it also makes a lovely gift. Not just for Christmas.
Verena: That was a nice closing. Thank you very much for taking the time. And, dear readers, of course I hope you enjoyed the interview and that you had fun.
Our products are free from animal ingredients. For the love of nature and your health.
We set the highest standards for our products. Genetic engineering and irradiation are just as taboo as drying temperatures above 45° C.
Nothing is as perfect as nature! Enjoy products of maximum naturalness, without synthetic vitamin additives, preservatives or fillers.
Keimling Naturkost decided many years ago in favour of a consistent renunciation of palm oil. Our range is 100% palm oil free.
Our suppliers practise controlled organic farming. This means no synthetic pesticides, no mineral fertilisers and certainly no genetic engineering.